AI Rebounding: Companies Are Rehiring the People AI Replaced

By Julien Boubel | 2026-11-09

Nearly one in five US workers in a new survey say they were replaced by AI and then asked to come back. Why it happens, what returning workers ask for, and how companies can avoid it.

TL;DR - In an SHL survey, 19% of US workers said they had been replaced by AI and later asked to return. - Robert Half found that 32% of US hiring managers whose organisations cut roles later had to bring back the same or similar positions. - The most common reason was that the work needed institutional knowledge or context that AI couldn't provide. - Workers who are asked back often want more pay, job security guarantees and clarity on how AI will be used. What the surveys found Talent assessment company SHL has a name for this: "AI rebounding". It's when a company replaces people with AI and then asks them to come back. SHL surveyed 2,036 employed adults in the US and UK in June and July 2026. Nearly one in five US respondents (19%) said it had happened to them. In the UK the figure was about one in eight (13%), and among 18 to 24 year olds it was nearly one in four (24%). SHL sells hiring and assessment tools, so keep in mind that this is vendor research. Employers report the same thing from the other side. In research from Robert Half, 32% of US hiring managers whose organisations had eliminated positions later had to reinstate the same or similar roles. Fortune covered both studies on November 9. Why companies end up rehiring Robert Half asked the hiring managers who reinstated roles what had gone wrong. The most common answers were: - The roles needed institutional knowledge or context AI couldn't replace (40%) - They involved managing relationships, which AI couldn't do (39%) - Business demand went up and the company needed the people (39%) - The work needed more human oversight and quality control than expected (38%) Most of these come down to planning.

Back to all articles